GST Litigation Shake-up: State Benches of GSTAT – A Step-by-Step Guide for Filing Your First Appeal

After a prolonged wait of nearly seven years since the inception of the Goods and Services Tax (GST) regime, India’s indirect tax litigation landscape is undergoing its most significant transformation yet. The Ministry of Finance, through Notification No. S.O. 1329(E) dated March 27, 2024, has officially notified the establishment of 31 State Benches of the GST Appellate Tribunal (GSTAT). This landmark development signals the end of a critical legislative void and promises to unclog the judicial pipeline, offering a ray of hope for thousands of businesses embroiled in tax disputes.

Also Read-RBI’s EDPMS and IDPMS: Real-Time Trade Monitoring

For years, the absence of a functional appellate tribunal has created a severe bottleneck in the GST dispute resolution mechanism. The statutory hierarchy intended a three-tiered structure: the Adjudicating Authority (the officer passing the initial order), the First Appellate Authority (typically a Joint or Additional Commissioner), and finally, the GSTAT. However, with the GSTAT existing only on paper, aggrieved taxpayers and the department had no recourse but to approach the respective High Courts by filing writ petitions.

This ad-hoc arrangement was fraught with problems. Writ jurisdiction is extraordinary and discretionary, meaning High Courts were not obligated to hear every case. Furthermore, these courts are already overburdened with cases spanning all areas of law. They are not specialized forums for dissecting the complex, fact-intensive, and technical nuances of GST law. The result was a costly and time-consuming process that placed an immense burden on both the judiciary and the taxpayers, particularly small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs).

The operationalization of GSTAT benches is the answer to this structural deficiency. As the designated second appellate authority, the GSTAT is a quasi-judicial body specifically constituted to hear appeals against the orders passed by the First Appellate Authority (under Section 107 of the CGST Act, 2017) and the Revisional Authority (under Section 108). Each bench, comprising a Judicial Member and a Technical Member (State and/or Centre), brings a blend of legal acumen and tax-specific expertise, ensuring that appeals are adjudicated on both technical merits and principles of law. This move is not just a procedural update; it is a fundamental restoration of the intended legal framework, promising faster, more specialized, and more accessible justice for all stakeholders in the GST ecosystem.

Your Step-by-Step Guide to Filing a GSTAT Appeal

With the GSTAT benches becoming a reality, taxpayers and tax professionals must urgently familiarize themselves with the precise procedures for filing an appeal. An error in timelines or documentation can prove fatal to a case. This guide breaks down the entire process under Section 112 of the Central Goods and Services Tax (CGST) Act, 2017.

Step 1: Determine Your Eligibility and Grounds for Appeal

Before you begin, confirm that your case is eligible for an appeal to the GSTAT. You can file an appeal if you are a person aggrieved by an order passed by:

1. The First Appellate Authority under Section 107 of the CGST Act.
2. The Revisional Authority under Section 108 of the CGST Act.

Your appeal must be built on solid “Grounds of Appeal.” These are not mere disagreements; they are specific, legally-sound arguments explaining why you believe the lower authority’s order is incorrect. These grounds could be based on an error of fact, a misinterpretation of the law, a violation of the principles of natural justice, or jurisdictional issues. It is crucial to draft these grounds clearly and concisely, supported by a “Statement of Facts” that chronologically lays out the history of the case.

Step 2: Adhere to the Strict Timelines

Time is of the essence in tax litigation. The law prescribes a strict window for filing an appeal with the GSTAT:

• Primary Timeline: The appeal must be filed within three months from the date on which the order being appealed against is communicated to you.
• Condonation of Delay: If you miss this deadline, the GSTAT has the power to condone the delay for a further period of up to three months, provided you can demonstrate “sufficient cause” for the delay. It is critical to note that the Tribunal has no power to accept an appeal filed beyond this total six-month period.

The GST Department also has the right to file an appeal if it is aggrieved by an order, and the same timeline generally applies.

Step 3: Calculate and Pay the Mandatory Pre-Deposit

This is one of the most critical and often misunderstood steps. To have your appeal admitted by the GSTAT, you must pay a mandatory pre-deposit. This is in addition to any amount paid at the first appeal stage. The calculation, as per Section 112(8) of the CGST Act, is as follows:

• A sum equal to twenty percent (20%) of the remaining amount of tax in dispute, arising from the said order.
• This is in addition to the ten percent (10%) of the disputed tax that you would have already paid while filing the appeal before the First Appellate Authority.

Effectively, to reach the GSTAT, a taxpayer must have pre-deposited a cumulative thirty percent (30%) of the total disputed tax amount.

Illustrative Example:
* Disputed tax in the original order (Order-in-Original): ₹20,00,000
* Pre-deposit for first appeal (10%): ₹2,00,000
* Order from First Appellate Authority upholds the entire demand.
* Pre-deposit for GSTAT appeal (20% of the disputed tax): ₹4,00,000
* Total amount pre-deposited to have the GSTAT appeal heard: ₹2,00,000 + ₹4,00,000 = ₹6,00,000

There is a monetary ceiling on this pre-deposit. The amount is capped at ₹50 Crore for CGST and ₹50 Crore for SGST/UTGST. In cases involving IGST, the cap is ₹100 Crore. Payment of the pre-deposit is typically made using Form GST DRC-03.

Step 4: Prepare and File the Appeal Application (Form GST APL-05)

The appeal to the GSTAT must be filed electronically on the GST portal using Form GST APL-05. While filling out the form, you will need to provide details of the order being appealed, the grounds of appeal, and the statement of facts. You must also prepare and upload scanned copies of the following essential documents:

1. The impugned order: The certified copy of the Order-in-Appeal (from the First Appellate Authority) or the Revisional Order that you are appealing against.
2. The original order: The copy of the Order-in-Original passed by the Adjudicating Authority.
3. Proof of Payment: The challan or document (e.g., acknowledgement from Form DRC-03) evidencing the payment of the mandatory 20% pre-deposit.
4. Grounds of Appeal and Statement of Facts: The detailed document outlining your case.
5. Supporting Documents: Any other evidence, case laws, or documents you are relying on to support your grounds of appeal.
6. Authorisation Letter/Vakalatnama: If you are being represented by a Chartered Accountant, advocate, or other authorized representative.

The online filing process on the GST portal would typically follow this path:
Login > Services > User Services > My Applications > Application Type: Appeal to Appellate Tribunal > New Application

After filling in all the details and uploading the necessary documents, the form must be signed/verified using a Digital Signature Certificate (DSC) or Electronic Verification Code (EVC).

Life After Filing: The Hearing Process and the Road Ahead

Once your appeal is successfully filed and admitted, the GSTAT will fix a date for the hearing and notify both parties. This is where the merits of your case will be argued. Effective representation by a knowledgeable professional is paramount. The Tribunal will hear arguments, examine the evidence submitted, and may ask for clarifications.

After the hearing is concluded, the GSTAT will pass its order under Section 113 of the CGST Act. The Tribunal has the power to:
* Confirm the original order.
* Modify the original order.
* Annul (set aside) the original order.
* Remand the case back to the original Adjudicating Authority or the First Appellate Authority for a fresh decision with specific directions.

The GSTAT’s order is binding on both the taxpayer and the GST department. It is a significant step towards legal finality.

However, the litigation journey may not end here. If a substantial question of law arises from the GSTAT’s order, a further appeal can be made. The final rungs of the litigation ladder are:

• The High Court: An appeal can be filed before the jurisdictional High Court under Section 117 if the case involves a “substantial question of law.” This is a higher threshold than simply disagreeing with the facts.
• The Supreme Court of India: The final appeal lies with the Supreme Court under Section 118, which can hear appeals from the High Court or directly from the GSTAT in specific cases, such as a conflict of decisions between State Benches.

A New Chapter in Indian Taxation.

The activation of GSTAT State Benches is more than an administrative milestone; it is a foundational reform that strengthens the architecture of India’s GST regime. It provides businesses with a dedicated, expert forum for second appeals, reducing their reliance on already strained High Courts and promising a more streamlined, efficient, and uniform system of dispute resolution.

While challenges in implementation and caseload management will inevitably arise, this is an unequivocally positive development. For businesses, the message is clear: understand the new process, adhere strictly to the timelines and requirements, and prepare to argue your cases before a specialized tribunal that is finally open for business. The long wait for a fair second hearing is over.

C.K. Gupta

Hello, I am C.K. Gupta owner of Taxgst.in, a seasoned finance professional with a Master of Commerce degree and over 20 years of experience in accounting and finance. My extensive career has been dedicated to mastering the intricacies of financial management, tax consultancy, and strategic planning. Throughout my professional journey, I have honed my skills in financial analysis, tax planning, and compliance, ensuring that all practices adhere to the latest financial regulations. My expertise also extends to auditing, where I focus on maintaining accuracy and integrity in financial reporting. I am passionate about using my knowledge to provide insightful and reliable financial advice, helping businesses optimize their financial strategies and achieve their economic goals. At Taxgst.in, I aim to share valuable insights that assist our readers in navigating the complex world of taxes and finance with ease.